Introduction
Over 250 delegates from 80 countries, representing governments, inter-governmental and non-governmental organizations (NGO), and academic institutions attended the World Summit on Physical Education (Berlin, November 3-5, 1999). It was held under the international patronage of the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and the International Olympic Committee (IOC), and with the co-sponsorship of the World Health Organization (WHO).
On behalf of the participants of the Summit and the International Council of Sport Science and Physical Education (ICSSPE), I present this paper to the Ministers and Senior Officials of Ministries responsible for Education and Sport for discussion at the MINEPS III meeting. The paper combines the latest research, content from keynote presentations and workgroup discussions from the World Summit.
The activities of ICSSPE reflect the interests of a diverse range of multi disciplinary and international member organizations. To date, two-hundred governmental and non-governmental bodies with international, regional, national or local membership form the Council's world-wide network. ICSSPE is a non-governmental organization in Formal Associate Relations with UNESCO.
The International Committee of Sport Pedagogy (ICSP) within ICSSPE links five international organizations with a common interest in physical education). This Committee is composed of: the Association Internationale des Ecoles Superieures d'Education Physique (AIESEP), the Federation Internationale d'Education Physique (FJ EP), the International Association of Physical Education and Sport for Girls and Women (IAPESGW), the International Federation of Adapted Physical Activity (IFAPA), and the International Society for Comparative Physical Education and Sport (ISGPES). The International Committee of Sports Pedagogy played a leading role in the development of this World Summit on Physical Education. The intention behind these plans has been to:
We welcome the opportunity to co-operate with Ministers and Senior Officials and hope that by working together, we can extend the benefits and joys of Physical Education to more children across the world.
Prof. Dr. Gudrun Doll-Tepper
President ICSSPE
The Challenge
Despite the overwhelming scientific evidence on the value of physical activity, and the fact that the 1978 UNESCO Charter enshrined Physical Education as a basic human right (see page 14), Physical Education is in a perilous position in all regions of the world. Some national governments have either removed Physical Education from the curriculum, or reduced curriculum time allocation.
". . . Physical Education is not seen as a priority
in the '90s. It is under severe attack and faces competition
for time within the school curriculum. Often Physical Education
is being taught by generalist teachers with little or no preparation
in Physical Education methods. Additionally, budget cutbacks
are having a negative impact on the time and resources required
to teach a quality Physical Education programme."
(Mo Mackendrick, President of the Canadian Association for Health,
Physical Education (CAH PER3) 1996)
In order to determine the extent of the problem, a world-wide audit (which included an extensive literature survey) of the state and status of Physical Education in schools was initiated by ICSSPE and funded by the International Olympic Committee. The International Committee on Sports Pedagogy played a leading role in ensuring the survey provided the kind of information needed to address and solve current challenges.
Dr. Ken Hardpan, University of Manchester, presented his audit results to set the scene for the World Summit on Physical Education. The audit results show the critical status of Physical Education around the world, regardless of geography or socio-economic status. Five key issues clearly define the challenge Physical Education is facing:
Sample quotations (in bold letters) and statistics are included. For a full copy of Dr. Hardpan's report, please contact the International Council of Sport Science and Physical Education.
Results of World-wide Survey on the State and Status of Physical Education
1. Statutory Requirements for Physical Education
In 92% of the 126 countries sampled, Physical Education is legally required but few countries actually implement their statutory requirements. Globally around 30% of Physical Education is dropped to make way for other subjects.
In a Province of Canada, it is estimated that 97.8% of schools may not meet the allotted Physical Education curriculum time.
In an African country, "It is not enforced. Some teachers do not teach it at all and nobody seems to bother" (Physical Education Professor)
In another African country, it is a compulsory subject, "yet the majority of schools do not present P.E. at all." (Physical Education professor)
2. Subject Status of Physical Education
In many regions of the world, Physical Education is perceived as being a non-productive educational activity, less important to a successful future than academic subjects. Physical Education occupies a low position at the bottom of the 'curriculum barrel'. Overall 86% of countries' respondents indicate that Physical Education has attained a similar legal status to other subjects, but this is not matched in practice.
In an Oceanian country, teachers have expressed concerns that the "image of Physical Education that perseveres with the school's management and other teaching staff renders it as a marginal subject... not worthy of valuable timetable space."
In a Latin American country, a Physical Education lecturer indicates that the state attaches little importance to Physical Education and continues to decrease its importance by reducing space for the subject and not providing facilities.
In a European country, the "status of Physical Education ... is an essential problem - (its) legal status is revealed by a low division of time for Physical Education confirmed through central school policy (and generally), the actual exercising status is lower than other subjects".
3. Curriculum Time Allocation
Most curriculum time is allocated when children are between 9-14 years of age, with reductions in time as age increases - especially in the upper years of schooling, when it either becomes an optional subject or it disappears from the timetable.
"Estimated activity levels increase during childhood into early adolescence, and then decline as youth pass through adolescence." (R. Malina, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)
In one European country more than half a million hours of Physical Education have been lost in primary schools in the year 1998-9 to make time for literacy and numeracy work.
In another European country, Physical Education time has been reduced from three hours a week to one hour a week during the last decade i.e. from 537 hours to 460 hours in the compulsory school years. "The sports days in school (have also been) canceled...(with) total reduction of movement in school ... to about a third."
In secondary schools in a Latin American country, Physical Education has been reduced from three to one or two classes per week.
4. Teacher Training
Too often Physical Education teachers in primary or elementary schools are untrained for the subject and some conduct Physical Education lessons as supervised play. Physical Education is taught by the classroom teacher who usually has had little or no training in Physical Education. There are more trained Physical Education teachers at the secondary level, but many Physical Education classes are still given by untrained teachers.
"On average post-graduate trainees do 23 hours and undergraduates 32 hours. But some do as little as seven-and-a-half." (Office for Standards in Education - England and Wales, 1999)
5. Resources
Funding for Physical Education is being disproportionately cut as government departments try and cope with reduced funding. The result is a loss in both the quantity and quality of Physical Education programs. Both the provision of facilities and their maintenance are inadequate in many schools world-wide. Globally, only 31% of countries have adequate facilities. In the less developed countries, there are greater challenges in providing a full range of facilities; but even in countries with more established systems of Physical Education, there were reports of poor maintenance and loss of facilities.
In a European country, "decreased funding has resulted in a reduction in the number of hours for Physical Education within several cantons, even though this contravenes the federally set minimum for the subject." (Physical Education teacher).
In a state of the USA, in some schools, shared facilities like "all purpose rooms (lunchroom, auditorium, gym) restrict accessibility; some urban schools do not have a gymnasium and have limited outdoor space";
whilst in another state of the USA, a teacher "... lost gym space over the summer (they turned one of our gyms into a library). We have a large number of students and some classes have to take place in the cafeteria ."
Overall, the findings of the survey indicate a widespread scepticism and pessimism for the future of school Physical Education. Physical Education has been pushed into a defensive position. It is suffering from decreasing time in the curriculum, budgetary controls with inadequate financial, material and human resources, and low subject status and esteem. It is being ever more marginalised and undervalued by authorities.
However, despite these problems, there were many examples of good practice across the world. In all cases, such quality Physical Education is led by teachers with good training and skills.
"Physical Education is at great risk of being lost altogether in the next five years due to the diminished and marginalised position the subject has found itself in." (Doecke, Papua New Guinea 1998)
Request to MINEPS III
At the World Summit on Physical Education (Berlin, November 3-5, 1999), 250 delegates from 80 countries representing governments, inter-governmental and non-governmental organizations and academic institutions from all regions of the world endorsed the Berlin Agenda and its Call for Action by Ministers and Senior Officials responsible for Education and Sport.
The Call for Action asks Officials at MINEPS III to endorse the Berlin Agenda (see Appendix 1) and the Call for Action asks Government leaders to undertake the following:
Rationale
As scientific data from around the world has consistently shown, quality Physical Education can meet a broad range of needs for all people, especially children and youth.
Quality Physical Education:
Research Findings
At the World Summit on Physical Education 1999, international delegates presented research evidence from around the globe on benefits of Physical Education and its important role in developing healthy, active children. Additional relevant research is also included. The physical domain of Physical Education emphases (1) instruction in motor skills and the opportunity to practice these skills in a supervised setting, (2) development and improvement of physical fitness, and (3) provision of physical activity on a regular basis in the school setting.
Benefits of Physical Education (and sport):
Positive Health Evidence
Evidence for Cognitive Development and Academic Achievement
Economic Evidence
Evidence for Inclusion
Physical Education is especially important for girls and women, special needs, and cultural groups, who are:
Quality Physical Education
At the World Summit on Physical Education, presenters (M. Talbot, W. Brettschneider, D. Solomons, B. Kidd, inter alia) outlined recommendations on quality Physical Education. This section includes the needs and components of a quality Physical Education experience.
Physical Education needs:
Children and young people, whatever their abilities and despite living in a wide range of countries and cultures, material circumstances, all:
Effective Physical Education has the following characteristics:
"Schools reach all young people - girls and boys,
the physically strong and the not so strong; the socially privileged
and the socially weak - thereby avoiding social inequality and
disintegration."
(D. Solomons, World Summit on Physical Education,1999)
All learners should be provided with a sound knowledge of healthy living and a safe way of living. As education is a life-long process, sound health and human movement practices can contribute to the prevention of health-related problems and can improve the quality of life of learners.
"Physical Education is the place for improving physical
fitness and developing motor skills. In addition, in Physical
Education classes young people are empowered to assume responsibility
for developing an interest in physical activity of their own
accord and for adopting an active lifestyle."
(W. Brettschneider, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)
"(..) Unfortunately, the reality is that not only
are the time mandates for Physical Education in public and private
schools continually decreasing, but there are many education
programmes world-wide whose curriculum does not include Physical
Education at all. Further, we should not confuse athletics with
physical education because they are not synonymous. [...]The
purpose and campaign of promoting physical activity through developmentally
appropriate Physical Education has never been more compelling.
We desperately need to develop an international commitment to
ensure that all children receive the encouragement, training
and support they need to develop and maintain active, healthy
lifestyles...),"
(M. Murray, 1999)
"... We cannot meet our obligations to make the world
a better place for our children without contributing significantly
to their physically active health and enrichment. We should hold
our leaders to that promise."
(B. Kidd, World Summit on Physical Education 1999)
Supporting Statements
This section is designed to provide resources for Ministers and Senior Officials to build the case for Physical Education at a local, regional or national level. It includes several examples of international policy statements.
"Article 1:
The practice of Physical Education and sport is a fundamental
right for all .
Article 2:
Physical Education and sport form an essential element of lifelong
education in the overall education system.
Article 3:
Physical Education and sport programmes must meet individual
and social need.
Article 4:
Teaching, coaching and administration of Physical Education and
sport programmes must meet individual and social needs.
Article 5:
Adequate facilities and equipment are essential to Physical Education
and sport.
Article 6:
Research and evaluation are indispensable components of the development
of Physical Education and sport.
Article 7:
Protection of the ethnical and moral values of Physical Education
and sport must be a constant concern for all.
Article 8:
Information and documentation help to promote Physical Education
and sport.
Article 9:
The mass media should exert a positive influence on Physical
Education and sport.
Article 10:
National institutions play a major role in Physical Education
and sport.
Article 11:
International co-operation is a prerequisite for the universal
and well-balanced promotion of Physical Education."
All students in every grade should have the right and opportunity to experience sustained, vigorous physical activity, and participate in quality, daily Physical Education programmes.
Physical Education:
The following Declaration was accepted by the participants:
"The Physical Education of Arab girls suffers from negative
attitudes towards girls' benefitting from school Physical Education,
which is a part of her life and future. In the light of the inadequacy
of the human and material resources and expertise needed for
practicing sport activities, and the low care shown by those
responsible for girls' Physical Education, this conference makes
the following declaration: Raise standards of school Physical
Education for Arab girls."
Conclusion
The world-wide survey on the state of Physical Education, and other international research provides an enormous challenge to address the status and resources for Physical Education. Most government Departments are working hard trying to balance the overwhelming number of requests for their limited resources However, when Physical Education is not incorporated as an integral part of education programmes, the consequences can be long-lasting and manifold.
Physical Education can provide a large number of health, social, cognitive and economic benefits. Physical Education can and does provide a Return on Investment (R013 in other areas of spending, most notably health. Based on the evidence presented in this paper, we ask the participants of the Third International Conference of Ministers and Senior Officials Responsible for Sport and Physical Activities (MINEPS III) to endorse the Berlin Agenda for Action and to implement the recommendations at the national, and local levels.
Working together we can make a difference for our most precious resource -- today's children and youth.
This is an international problem requiring international, regional and national action
Annex 1
The Berlin Agenda for Action for Government Ministers
The World Summit on Physical Education reinforces the
importance of Physical Education as a
life-long process. It is particularly important for every child
as articulated in the International Convention on the Rights
of the Child. All children have a right to (1) the highest level
of health; (2) free and compulsory primary education for both
cognitive and physical development; (3) rest and leisure; play
and recreation.
THE BERLIN AGENDA CALLS FOR ACTION BY GOVERNMENTS AND MINISERIES RESPONSIBLE FOR EDUCATION AND SPORT TO:
Why take these actions? Quality Physical Education:
BERLIN, November 5, 1999
Appeal of the World Summit on Physical Education to the General Conference of UNESCO
The representatives of states, intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations, and educational institutions at the World Summit on Physical Education, held in BERLIN from November 3-5, 1999.
Considering the importance of Physical Education for every child around the world, and its role in encouraging people to remain active and healthy throughout their life-span,
Considering that Physical Education helps to ensure integrated and rounded development of mind, body and spirit and contributes to children's confidence and self-esteem,
Emphasizing that Physical Education can enhance cognitive, academic achievement and social development including fundamental educational skills like literacy, and numeracy.
Noting that Physical Education is the most effective and inclusive means of providing children, whatever their ability, age, sex, cultural or religious background, with the skills, knowledge and understanding for lifelong participation in physical activity and sport,
Reaffirming that Physical Education provides skills and knowledge for employment in sport, physical activity, public health, recreation and leisure, a growing area of vocational opportunity,
Reaffirming that Physical Education provides an ethical and social foundation for the spirit of fair play, mutual respect, solidarity and human understanding.
Scientific Programme of the World Summit on Physical Education
Programme highlights / Keynotes
Workshops